Betting-picks 4 min read

Cowboys at Giants Betting Pick: Week 1

The Dallas Cowboys start their 2023 season on the road at the NFC East division rivals New York Giants. Here are our picks.

Published September 5, 2023 Updated March 31, 2026
John Mehaffey
John Mehaffey
Lead Sports Betting Analyst
Cowboys at Giants Betting Pick: Week 1

Article Content

On Sunday, September 10th, the Giants are hosting the Cowboys at MetLife Stadium. This week 1 NFL matchup kicks off at 8:20 ET with NBC carrying the television coverage.

The odds for this week 1 NFC East matchup have the Cowboys as the 3 point favorites against the spread. Read on to get our betting insights for this week 1 matchup.

Betting Odds for Giants vs. Cowboys

  • Spread: Cowboys -3 | Giants +3
  • Total: 46.5
  • MoneyLine: Cowboys -175 | Giants +141

Why You Should Bet on the Giants

Last season, the Giants put together a regular season record of 9-7-1 and finished 3rd in the NFC-East. New York’s season came to an end in a Divisional Round loss to the Eagles (38-7). The Giants went 1-5-1 in divisional games last season. At home, they put together a record of 5-3-1 while going 5-5 on the road.

Against the spread, the Giants put together a record of 13-5-1 on an average scoring margin of -1.6 points per game. As the favorite, the Giants were 3-2 vs. the spread while going 10-3-1 (ATS) as the underdog. New York’s over/under record came in at 8-11.

Last season, Daniel Jones completed 67.2% of his passes for a total of 3205 yards. For the season, he finished 15th among QB’s in passing yards and 13th in touchdowns (15). Jones’ passer rating for the season was 92.5 (23rd).

In the backfield, the Giants are welcoming back Saquon Barkley who is the team’s top returning running back in terms of attempts and is coming off a season in which he finished with 1312 rushing yards and averaged 4 yards per attempt. Barkley is entering his 6th season in the league.

Daniel Jones will be relying on Darius Slayton, who led the Giants’ wide receiver group last season with 724 receiving yards while hauling in two touchdowns.

Why You Should Bet on the Cowboys

In the 2022-2023 season, the Cowboys finished with a regular season record of 12-5 and were 2nd in the NFC-East. The season’s end arrived with a Divisional Round loss to the 49ers by a score of 19-12. Within divisional games, the Cowboys went 4-2. At home, they fnished with a record of 8-1, while on the road, they were 5-5.

Dallas’ over/under record last season wrapped up at 9-10 with their games averaging 46.6 points per contest. When looking at how they finished vs. the spread, they were 11-8 with an average scoring margin of +7.1 points per game.

Last season, Dak Prescott completed 66.2% of his passes for a total of 2860 yards. For the season, he finished 20th among QB’s in passing yards and 8th in touchdowns (23). Prescott’s passer rating for the season was 91.1 (26th).

In the backfield, the Cowboys are welcoming back Tony Pollard who is the team’s top returning running back in terms of attempts and is coming off a season in which he finished with 1007 rushing yards and averaged 5 yards per attempt. Pollard is entering his 5th season in the league.

Dak Prescott will be relying on CeeDee Lamb, who led the Cowboys’ wide receiver group last season with 1359 receiving yards while hauling in nine touchdowns.

Final Prediction & Where To Bet

After the lines opened with the Cowboys favored by 2.5, the Cowboys have now become even more of a favorite, currently sitting at -3.

My point-spread pick for this Cowboys vs. Giants matchup is to take the Giants to cover at home. As of now, they are 3-point underdogs and I expect them to cover at this number.

  • BetByState Expert Pick: Giants +3

Where to Bet This Game

For most of our picks posts, we recommend only a few sportsbooks if you’re looking to actually bet for real money! With the abrupt closure of such prominent brands like WynnBet and FoxBet, it’s important to place your trust in only the most reputable players in the industry.

This is why we recommend the below sportsbooks when it comes it comes to signing up for a new account and taking advantage of all the new player bonus offers, including tons of bonus bets back — just in time for football season!

Related Articles

The use of live sports-betting features and the risk of gambling harm
Responsible Gambling

The use of live sports-betting features and the risk of gambling harm
Treat Online Poker Like Horseracing and Sports Betting
Opinion

Treat Online Poker Like Horseracing and Sports Betting
How to Bet on March Madness College Basketball
Sports Betting

How to Bet on March Madness College Basketball

About the Author - E-E-A-T Verified

John Mehaffey

John Mehaffey

Lead Sports Betting Analyst

Twitter/X LinkedIn

John Mehaffey is a veteran sports betting journalist with over 15 years of experience covering the US regulated gambling industry. He has reported on the evolution of American sports betting from the repeal of PASPA in 2018 through the rapid expansion of legal sportsbooks across 38+ states. His work focuses on sportsbook reviews, regulatory analysis, and consumer education — helping bettors make informed decisions in a rapidly changing landscape.

Credentials & Experience
  • 15+ years covering US sports betting & gambling regulation
  • Covered PASPA repeal and subsequent state-by-state legalization
  • Member of the National Council on Problem Gambling (NCPG)
  • Former contributor to ESPN, Action Network, and Legal Sports Report
  • Personally tested and reviewed 30+ licensed US sportsbooks
  • Quoted in The New York Times, Washington Post, and Bloomberg
Hands-On Testing

John has placed legal wagers in 20+ states, tested every major sportsbook app firsthand, and maintains direct relationships with sportsbook operators and state regulators. His reviews are based on hands-on testing of deposits, withdrawals, customer support, odds competitiveness, and mobile app experience.